That Susan Rice either willfully misled the American people on the Benghazi attacks, or lazily absorbed intelligence briefings without the least bit of personal involvement, is obvious. That she was covering for the Obama Administration in denying a terror attack just weeks before the election is speculative but likely. That she does not, therefore, deserve to become Secretary of State is arguable. But what is not arguable is that she deserves to be denied the post for a different reason altogether: Rwanda. What emerges when taken together -- Rice's weak response in Benghazi, blaming the murder of four Americans on a stupid video, and her shameful lack of action in the Rwandan genocide -- is a career diplomat of singular weakness, lacking the spine or muscularity to assert American moral influence in the world. Rice was part of Bill Clinton's National Security Team that in 1994 refused any involvement whatsoever in the Rwanda genocide, leaving more than 800,000 men, women, and children to be hacked to death by machete in the fastest genocide ever recorded. The Clinton Administration had just been spooked by the Black Hawk down incident in Somalia and wanted no further foreign entanglements. But the lengths to which they went to deny assistance to the Tutsis, with Rice being central to the decision-making process, will forever live in infamy. But not content to insist on American non-involvement, the Clinton administration went a step further by obstructing the efforts of other nations to stop the slaughter. On April 21, 1994, the Canadian UN commandeer in Rwanda, General Romeo Dallaire, declared that he required only 5000 troops to bring the genocide to a rapid halt. In addition, a single bombing run against the RTLM Hutu Power radio transmitting antenna would have made it impossible for the Hutus to coordinate their genocide. But on the very same day, as Phillip Gourevitch explains in his definitive account of the Rwandan genocide, We Wish to Inform You that Tomorrow We will Be Killed with Our Families, the Security Council, with the Clinton Administration's blessing, ordered the UN force under Dallaire reduced by ninety percent to a skeleton staff of 270 troops who would powerlessly witness the slaughter to come. This, in turn, was influenced by Presidential Decision Directive 25, which "amounted to a checklist of reasons to avoid American involvement in UN peacekeeping missions," even though Dallaire did not seek American troops and the mission was not peacekeeping but genocide prevention. Indeed, Madeleine Albright, the American Ambassador to the UN, opposed leaving even this tiny UN force. She also pressured other countries "to duck, as the death toll leapt from thousands to tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands... the absolute low point in her career as a stateswoman." In a 2001 article published in The Atlantic, Samantha Power, author of the Pulitzer-Prize winning A Problem of Hell and arguably the world's foremost voice against genocide and who currently serves on the National Security Council as an aide to President Obama, referred to Ambassador Susan Rice and her colleagues in the Clinton Administration as Bystanders to Genocide. She quotes Rice in the 2002 book as saying, "If we use the word 'genocide' and are seen as doing nothing, what will be the effect on the November congressional election?" Rice's subordination of a human tragedy of epic proportions to partisan politic interests mirrors the current allegations of why she denied a terror attack in Benghazi. Rice then joined Madeline Albright, Anthony Lake and Warren Christopher as part of a coordinated effort not only to impede UN action to stop the Rwanda genocide, but to minimize public opposition to American inaction by removing words like "genocide" and "ethnic cleansing" from government communications on the subject. In the end, eight African nations, fed up with American inaction, agreed to send in an intervention force to stop the slaughter provided that the U.S. would lend them fifty armored personal carriers. The Clinton Administration decided it would lease rather than lend the armor for a price of $15 million. The carriers sat on a runway in Germany while the UN pleaded for a $5 million reduction as the genocidal inferno raged. The story only gets worse from there, with the Clinton State Department refusing to label the Rwanda horrors a genocide because of the 1948 Genocide Convention that would have obligated the United States to intervene, an effort that Susan Rice participated in. I recently met Gourevitch at a press conference I hosted for the Rwandan Minister of Foreign Affairs, Louise Mushikiwabo, where she announced that Rwanda would be opening an Embassy in Israel in the next six months. It was an honor for me to encounter an American who had done so much to highlight the brutal slaughter of innocent Africans while the most powerful country on earth did nothing. But why honor Susan Rice for the ignominy of doing nothing while six in Rwanda died every minute. Why elevate a woman so oblivious to American moral principles and the value of African life that she thought we out to sit this one out? It was painful enough to watch Kofi Anan elevated to Secretary General even though as head of UN peace-keeping forces worldwide he sent two now infamous cables to Dallaire forbidding him from any efforts to stop the genocide (the cables are on display in the Kigali Genocide Memorial where I visited in the summer). But to elevate Rice would make a mockery of those who believe that "Never Again" ought to mean just what is says. Better that Rice remain where she is. An ambassador whose spinelessness perfectly matches the organization she's in. Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, whom Newsweek and The Washington Post calls "the most famous Rabbi in America," is the international best-selling author of 29 books, and will shortly publish "The Fed-up Man of Faith: Challenging G-d in the Face of Tragedy and Suffering." His website is www.shmuley.com. Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley. |
Saturday, 15 December 2012
Rice's Failure in Rwanda Precludes Her From Becoming Secretary of State
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
READ MORE RECENT NEWS AND OPINIONS
-
▼
2012
(753)
-
▼
December
(233)
- USA: Experts Forecast the Cost of Failure to Compr...
- USA: Experts Forecast the Cost of Failure to Compr...
- Region sucked into conflict as eastern Congo becom...
- Region sucked into conflict as eastern Congo becom...
- Rwanda schemed M23 war - UN expert
- Rwanda schemed M23 war - UN expert
- Final report of the Group of Experts on the DRC su...
- Final report of the Group of Experts on the DRC su...
- Final report of the Group of Experts on the DRC su...
- Final report of the Group of Experts on the DRC su...
- Rapport final du Groupe d’experts sur la Républiqu...
- Rapport final du Groupe d’experts sur la Républiqu...
- Rwanda: Victoire Ingabire’s Speech and Quotes
- Rwanda: Victoire Ingabire’s Speech and Quotes
- Rwanda’s Rampaging Rebel Force - NYTimes.com
- Rwanda’s Rampaging Rebel Force - NYTimes.com
- The US and the Genocide in Rwanda 1994
- The US and the Genocide in Rwanda 1994
- US chose to ignore Rwandan genocide
- US chose to ignore Rwandan genocide
- The US was behind the Rwandan Genocide
- The US was behind the Rwandan Genocide
- A Dangerous Impasse: Rwandan Refugees in Uganda
- A Dangerous Impasse: Rwandan Refugees in Uganda
- Example of the UK policy manoeuvrings in Rwanda
- Example of the UK policy manoeuvrings in Rwanda
- STATE COLLAPSE AND REGIONAL CONTAGION IN SUB-SAHAR...
- STATE COLLAPSE AND REGIONAL CONTAGION IN SUB-SAHAR...
- RWANDAN ECONOMY AND FOREIGN AID
- RWANDAN ECONOMY AND FOREIGN AID
- A Dangerous Impasse: Rwandan Refugees in Uganda
- Foreign Policy: Kagame makes the Naughty list...
- Foreign Policy: Kagame makes the Naughty list...
- Does the U.S. Support Destabilization in the DR Co...
- DRC/The Root: What the World Owes Congo
- Kagame, les métamorphoses d'un tyran
- Does the U.S. Support Destabilization in the DR Co...
- Does the U.S. Support Destabilization in the DR Co...
- Victoire Ingabire spends her third Christmas behin...
- Victoire Ingabire spends her third Christmas behin...
- Is Rwanda under Kagame becoming the next Zimbabwe?
- Is Rwanda under Kagame becoming the next Zimbabwe?
- Victoire Ingabire: message of strength, dedication...
- Victoire Ingabire: message of strength, dedication...
- [AUDIO] Victoire Ingabire's Third Christmas in Prison
- [AUDIO] Victoire Ingabire's Third Christmas in Prison
- Vietnam, Afghanistan, Somalia … Congo? The DRC?
- Vietnam, Afghanistan, Somalia … Congo? The DRC?
- UN Accuse Bishop John Rucyahana of Supporting Murd...
- UN Accuse Bishop John Rucyahana of Supporting Murd...
- BBC: Can Uganda cope with three times as many people?
- BBC: Can Uganda cope with three times as many people?
- New Pentagon effort will send Army teams to Africa...
- New Pentagon effort will send Army teams to Africa...
- At last Hissène Habré to be tried by the Senegales...
- At last Hissène Habré to be tried by the Senegales...
- John Kerry: 'the perfect choice' for secretary of ...
- John Kerry: 'the perfect choice' for secretary of ...
- Prevent the the cessation of refugee status for Rw...
- Kagame Threatens to Return to the Bush
- Kagame Threatens to Return to the Bush
- Prevent the the cessation of refugee status for Rw...
- Stop Donating to West – President
- Stop Donating to West – President
- Susan Rice’s defense of Kagame in Congo puts Obama...
- Susan Rice’s defense of Kagame in Congo puts Obama...
- U.S. under pressure over Rwanda involvement in Con...
- U.S. under pressure over Rwanda involvement in Con...
- Prevent the the cessation of refugee status for Rw...
- Ben Affleck urged Washington to use its “unique” i...
- Ben Affleck urged Washington to use its “unique” i...
- Obama urges Rwandan president to stop support for ...
- Obama urges Rwandan president to stop support for ...
- Book: Transitional Justice in Rwanda-Accountabilit...
- Book: Transitional Justice in Rwanda-Accountabilit...
- Book: Britain's Hidden Role in the Rwandan Genocide
- Book: Britain's Hidden Role in the Rwandan Genocide
- Worries grow in east Congo with fighter buildup
- Worries grow in east Congo with fighter buildup
- 2012 Person of the Year: Barack Obama, the President
- 2012 Person of the Year: Barack Obama, the President
- Fw: *DHR* U.N. chief pushes for regional deal to e...
- Fw: *DHR* U.N. chief pushes for regional deal to e...
- Readout of the President’s Call with President Kagame
- Readout of the President’s Call with President Kagame
- Obama tells Rwanda: end DRC rebel support | The Au...
- Obama tells Rwanda: end DRC rebel support | The Au...
- US hits more DRC rebel leaders with sanctions : Ne...
- US hits more DRC rebel leaders with sanctions : Ne...
- Obama tells Rwanda to end DRC rebel support - FRAN...
- Obama tells Rwanda to end DRC rebel support - FRAN...
- RNC-IHURIRO AND FDU-INKINGI ENCOURAGED BY PRESIDEN...
- RNC-IHURIRO AND FDU-INKINGI ENCOURAGED BY PRESIDEN...
- Rwanda: Political prisoner Ingabire files an appea...
- Rwanda: Political prisoner Ingabire files an appea...
- Victoire Ingabire: An unwieldy trophy for RPF’s 25...
- Victoire Ingabire: An unwieldy trophy for RPF’s 25...
- Rwanda : Le FPR dans son bilan de 25 ans n’a pas a...
- Rwanda : Le FPR dans son bilan de 25 ans n’a pas a...
- Obama purportedly to nominate Kerry, sparking spec...
-
▼
December
(233)
Popular Posts
-
"The Tutsi people originated in Ethiopia when it was known as Kush and was a Jewish kingd...
-
Please, nababwiye kenshi ko ntakeneye izi message zanyu. Sinzi n'uburyo mwabonye e-mail ya...
-
http://www.salem-news.com/articles/october162012/danger-rwanda-jf.php Oct-16-2012 20:54 'A little knowledge is a dangerous thing. So i...
-
----- Forwarded Message ----- From: "agnesmurebwayire@yahoo.fr" <agnesmu...
-
The Congo's Forgotten Colonial Getaway An island in the Congo River was once a prime vacation hub and prosperous rubber plantation. ...
-
Atrocities in Rwanda, 2014 | A Living Text Atrocities in Rwanda, 2014 | A Living...
-
http://m.news24.com/kenya/MyNews24/Museveni-Kagame-will-take-Uhuru-to-Hague-20141002 Museveni,...
-
Stephen Rapp: Whitewashed Rwandan Genocide to absolve US culpability Sun, 2014-01-12 15:28 — ...
-
http://www.inyenyerinews.org/amakuru-2/the-untold-stories-will-the-rwandan-dictator-become-the-next-guatemalas-rios-montt-in-his-own-courts/...
-
Canadian lawyer wins legal battle over Rwanda charges HERWIG VERGULT / AFP/GETTY IMAGES fi...
“The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish.”
“I have loved justice and hated iniquity: therefore I die in exile.”
“The price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men.”
“When the white man came we had the land and they had the bibles; now they have the land and we have the bibles.”
Useful Links
- African Science News Service, ASNS
- AfricanCrops.net
- African Conservation Tillage Network, ACT
- African Centre for Technology Studies
- Afrik.com
- Think Africa Press
- Websites on Africa
- Royal African Society
- African Women's Organisations
- Claiming Human Rights
- LINKS OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
- IRIN News Links
- Africa Desk
- The African Studies Companion: A Guide to Information Sources
- Africa Portal
- The African Studies Centre in Leiden
- Organisations Working in Africa
- Africa Studies Center
- The ASAUK ( Africa Studies Association of the UK)
- A Guide to Africa on the Internet
- Africa Selected Internet Resources
- Ashoka
- Arid Lands Information Network
- Arid Lands Newsletter
- ApproTEC
- Annan, Kofi - The Causes of Conflict and the Promotion of Durable Peace and Sustainable Development in Africa
- American Friends Service Committee (Quakers)
- Agridoc - Medagri
- Agricultural University of Norway
- Agricola (National Agricultural Library)
- Agence de la Francophonie
- Afristat, l'Observatoire Economique et Statistique d'Afrique Subsaharienne
- Afrigadget
- Africare
- African Youth Foundation
- African Science News Service, ASNS
- African Population Database Documentation
- African Market
- African Leadership and Progress Network
- African Journal of Food, Agriculture, Nutrition and Development
- African Forum & Network on Debt & Development (AFRODAD)
- African Finance and Economics Association (AFEA)
- African Development Foundation, ADF
- African Development Forum 2002 - AllAfrica.com
- African Development Forum III (U.N. Economic Commission for Africa, March 3-8, 2002, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia)
- African Development Bank
- AfricanCrops.net
- African Conservation Tillage Network, ACT
- African Centre for Technology Studies
- African Centre for Economic Growth
- African Capacity Building Foundation
- Africa Works
- Africa Renewal (formerly Africa Recovery) (New York, NY)
- Africa Focus - Africa: Remittances Update
- Africa Files
- Africa Development / Afrique et Developpement
- Africa Can | End Poverty
- Africa Business Information Services
No comments:
Post a Comment