Skip to main content

USA: Professor and Rwandan refugee team up for film


Professor and Rwandan refugee team up for film

By Dylan Fahoome

Published: Monday, March 11, 2013

Updated: Monday, March 11, 2013

rawanda day

Creative Commons

Banners commemorating the 18th anniversary of the Rwandan genocide outside a Catholic church in Nyamata, Rwanda. "Stateless," a documentary produced by DePaul CDM Professor Scott Erlinder, brings light to a 'cessation clause' that could affect Rwandan refugees.

There's a phrase Scott Erlinder loves to use from President Kagame of Rwanda: "The way that you change things is you empty your neighbor's rain barrel with a spoon because they'll never notice it."

Erlinder, an assistant professor of cinematography and visual effects in the col­lege of computing and digital media at DePaul, has recently finished a film on the current state of affairs in Rwanda, with the goal to do precisely the opposite.

"We're trying to take all those spoons and put it back into the rain barrel so peo­ple can see what's going on," said Erlinder.

Erlinder was working on a film about Rwanda retelling what people already knew about the 1994 genocide and the re­cent refugee crisis when he first met Mu­tuyimana Manzi through Barbara Harrell-Bond, the founder of the Refugee Studies Center at Oxford University.

"She put me in touch with Manzi and he had been working with a group called the Refugee Law Project," said Erlinder.

Erlinder needed to videotape a confer­ence in Kampala along with interviews of Rwandan refugees for the film. Since he did not speak Kinyarwanda and knew Manzi could speak and work from his lo­cation in Uganda, a new partnership was born.

"I decided to rent him a camera to cover both of those things and that was sort of the start of our collaboration," said Erlinder.

Manzi and Erlinder began exchang­ing emails and worked together for about a year and a half until Erlinder was forced to pause and consider something serious. The Rwandan government had tried to as­sassinate Manzi because of his filming on three separate occasions.

"After the third incident I felt do I owe an obligation to this guy," said Erlinder. "I mean he's helped me. That happened in July of this year so in August my wife and I said we've got to get him out of there. It was obvious that if we left him in Uganda that something bad was going to happen."

Erlinder and his wife talked to Manzi and asked him if he could go to school any­where, what he would want to study.

"He said he wanted to write for a news­paper or something like that and I said, 'Well Manziyou realize what you've been doing is already being a journalist, in fact a video journalist,'" said Erlinder. "I saw a lot of talent in him."

Erlinder and his wife then tried to bring him back to the United States from Ugan­da, butErlinder says now he still doesn't even know how they made it happen.

Manzi did not have a passport because he was living as a refugee in Uganda. The only papers he had were from the UN Ref­ugee Agency, making it difficult to apply for visas as a technically 'stateless' person.

After much wrangling, Manzi managed to get an F-1 Student Visa and Erlinder se­cured him a scholarship to get started at DePaul's communication school.

"Until the day I was able to board the plane, until the day I was at O'Hare air­port, it wasn't really what was happen­ing," said Manzi, whose experience here as a 28-year-old undergraduate student Erlinder described as a being a 'tornado'.

"Sometimes I was thinking, 'I am dreaming… I am going to wake up,'" said Manzi.

Manzi's journey to Chicago was one that often seemed impossible.

"He thinks God himself didn't know for sure after his visa interview," said Priya Yavagal, an editor who collaborated with Erlinder on the film. "Until you actually saw him get out of O'Hare it was like we had no idea what's going on. It's like he had to be here. So he's here."

The film "Stateless," which was re­cently completed, is a short 47 minute doc­umentary that brings light to the 'cessation clause' pending before the U.N. that could affect Manzi and other Rwandan refugees.

The clause that could pass in an up­coming June 30 U.N. session requires agreement among African countries host­ing Rwandan expatriates. The cessation clause would remove refugee status for those who sought sanctuary between 1959 and 1998 in neighboring countries, declar­ing those who refuse to return to Rwanda after the invocation as "stateless people," according to the film's website.

But Erlinder has hope the cessation might fail again.

"They've tried to institute this clause four times and it's failed for one reason or another usually because the circumstances haven't proven to be what the UN says they should be," said Erlinder. "So they tried a different approach this time and refugees that were out of the country from 1959 to 1998… it's this first group but we feel it's sort of this nibbling approach – we'll get these people and it's a precedent to get the other ones to push the other ones back."

The film describes the state of Rwan­dan refugees currently as being in a 'hu­man limbo' without nationality, yet forced to live in impoverished conditions and camps in neighboring countries.

In 2010, the New York Times reported that about 1,700 Rwandans seeking asy­lum were driven to several trucks at gun­point and taken back into Rwanda against their will from Kampala, Uganda.

Manzi himself had fled to Uganda in 2006, and feels that Rwanda is under a re­gime and not a government.

"When you want the truth and justice in Rwanda, you are described as a geno­cide denier," said Manzi. "When you are fighting for democracy in Rwanda, they are going to frame you as someone [with] genocide ideology and someone threaten­ing national security."

Comments

Be the first to comment on this article!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Le Troisième Mandat de Louise Mushikiwabo à l'OIF : Entre Précédent et Principe Démocratique.

Le Troisième Mandat de Louise Mushikiwabo à l'OIF : Entre Précédent et Principe Démocratique. L'Alternance à l'OIF : Pourquoi un Troisième Mandat Fragilise la Crédibilité de la Francophonie. Introduction Louise Mushikiwabo veut un troisième mandat à la tête de l'Organisation internationale de la Francophonie. Son annonce, faite bien avant l'émergence d'autres candidats, rappelle une tactique familière en Afrique : affirmer qu'on a le soutien populaire sans jamais le prouver publiquement. La méthode est rodée. Des dirigeants africains l'utilisent depuis des décennies pour prolonger leur règne. Ils clament que "le peuple le demande" ou que "les partenaires soutiennent" cette reconduction. Aucune preuve formelle n'est nécessaire. L'affirmation devient réalité politique. Mais voilà le problème : la Francophonie prêche la démocratie, l'État de droit et l'alternance au pouvoir. Peut-elle tolérer en son sein ce qu...

Pourquoi les sanctions américaines contre le Rwanda sont-elles si importantes ?

Pourquoi les sanctions américaines contre le Rwanda sont-elles si importantes ? Auteur : The African Rights Campaign. Londres, Royaume-Uni Publié en : mars 2026   Introduction Lorsqu'un gouvernement est accusé d'exécutions extrajudiciaires, de déplacements massifs, de violences sexuelles, de violations des droits de l'homme et du pillage systématique des ressources naturelles d'un pays voisin, la réponse diplomatique attendue est un démenti catégorique, étayé par des preuves. Le Rwanda ne l'a pas fait. Lorsque le département américain du Trésor a imposé des sanctions aux Forces de défense rwandaises (FDR) et à quatre de leurs commandants les plus haut placés, le 2 mars 2026, la porte-parole officielle de Kigali, Yolande Makolo, a délivré une déclaration que les analystes diplomatiques étudieront attentivement pour ce qu'elle omet conspicuement. Elle a dit que les sanctions étaient « injustes », qu'elles ciblaient « uniquement...

Rubaya Mine Under USA’s Control: Kagame Has No Grounds to Object.

Rubaya Mine: Strategic Interests, Regional Conflict and the DRC–USA Cooperation Framework Rubaya mine, located in Masisi territory in North Kivu, eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo, is a Congolese resource. It was a Congolese resource before the M23 advanced on it, it remains a Congolese resource today, and it will remain a Congolese resource regardless of what any regional actor claims, implies or pursues. That is not a political position. It is a statement of international law and sovereign right. This foundational point must be stated plainly because it is frequently obscured in discussions about the conflict in eastern Congo. Debates about security narratives, mineral partnerships and geopolitical alignment risk creating a false impression that Rubaya's ownership or governance is somehow open to negotiation between external parties. It is not. The Democratic Republic of the Congo holds sovereign authority over its territory and its natural resources. N...

BBC News

Africanews

UNDP - Africa Job Vacancies

How We Made It In Africa – Insight into business in Africa

Migration Policy Institute