Skip to main content

Kayumba Nyamwasa refugee status case goes to S.A. High Court

http://www.rnanews.com/politics/6585-kayumba-nyamwasa-refugee-status-case-goes-to-sa-high-court

Kayumba Nyamwasa refugee status case goes to S.A. High Court

E-mail Print

Lt Gen Kayumba Nyamwasa attends court in a separate case where 6 men are accused of trying to kill him in June 2010

Kigali: The South African High Court on Monday next week opens hearing of the case in which two groups are challenging their government's decision to grant refugee status to exiled ex-Rwanda army chief Lt Gen Kayumba Nyamwasa, RNA reports.

Back in early 2011, the Consortium for Refugees and Migrants Rights in South Africa (CoRMSA) and the Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC) asked their government to explain to the South African people how it granted asylum to Gen Kayumba, describing him as a "war criminal".

"No meaningful response was received and no indication that Nyamwasa's refugee claim was revisited was given," say the two groups in a statement released Thursday.

Then in June the 2011, the organizations went to court to force the government to give a "substantive explanation" and calling for Kayumba's refugee status to be revoked. The refusal to engage with the issues raised in the briefing paper necessitated the initiation of legal proceedings, according to the organizations.

Now the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has scheduled the hearing for Monday and Tuesday next week. Judge Mngqibisa-Thusi will be handling the case.

"In terms of South African and international law, people accused of international crimes are not eligible for refugee status," said Nicole Fritz, Director of SALC. "This decision is not only unlawful but it is offensive to those in genuine need of South Africa's protection and sends a signal to war criminals the world over that they will find a safe haven here – a haven where they might be actively protected as refugees."

The South African organisations give a detailed account of the war crimes charges against Gen Kayumba. They say "credible reports implicate" him in the commission of "grave human rights violations" in this region that amount to "crimes against humanity and war crimes".

In early 2010, when cases of corruption and embezzlement surfaced in Rwanda, Kayumba fled to South Africa. The Government of Rwanda has also pinned him on a spate of fatal grenade attacks around the country that killed several people around February 2010.

In January 2011, Rwanda's Military Court sentenced Kayumba in absentia, along with his current colleagues in arms Patrick Karegeya, Dr Theogene Rudasingwa and Gerald Gahima.

The South African groups also name the 2008 indictments in which Spanish Judge Fernando Andreu Merelles wants the exiled General-turned politician to answer for various war crimes charges.

"The Spanish indictment maintains Nyamwasa was responsible for the massacre of 2500 refugees and the murder of four Spanish nationals, amongst other serious crimes," say the organisations in their submission to court, in which 2006 contested indictments by French Judge Jean Louise Bruguiere, is named.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Le Troisième Mandat de Louise Mushikiwabo à l'OIF : Entre Précédent et Principe Démocratique.

Le Troisième Mandat de Louise Mushikiwabo à l'OIF : Entre Précédent et Principe Démocratique. L'Alternance à l'OIF : Pourquoi un Troisième Mandat Fragilise la Crédibilité de la Francophonie. Introduction Louise Mushikiwabo veut un troisième mandat à la tête de l'Organisation internationale de la Francophonie. Son annonce, faite bien avant l'émergence d'autres candidats, rappelle une tactique familière en Afrique : affirmer qu'on a le soutien populaire sans jamais le prouver publiquement. La méthode est rodée. Des dirigeants africains l'utilisent depuis des décennies pour prolonger leur règne. Ils clament que "le peuple le demande" ou que "les partenaires soutiennent" cette reconduction. Aucune preuve formelle n'est nécessaire. L'affirmation devient réalité politique. Mais voilà le problème : la Francophonie prêche la démocratie, l'État de droit et l'alternance au pouvoir. Peut-elle tolérer en son sein ce qu...

Rwanda's Security Narrative and Eastern DRC: Why Many Say It Is Overstated

Rwanda's Security Narrative and Eastern DRC: Why Many Say It Is Overstated Introduction Rwanda frequently presents itself as a militarily capable state, yet it claims it must cross into the Democratic Republic of the Congo to protect itself. This argument raises a fundamental question: if Rwanda possesses such military strength, why cannot it defend itself within its own borders? Critics argue that ongoing cross-border operations, civilian displacement, mineral exploitation, and the establishment of parallel administrations cannot be justified as legitimate self-defence. This perspective is not marginal. It reflects mainstream reasoning across Congolese civil society, regional commentary, and an increasing number of international briefings that examine patterns of territorial control, governance structures, and political economy rather than focusing solely on immediate cross-border threats. A fundamental principle underpins this critique: whilst any state is entitled to hav...

How Rwanda Got It Wrong: The Moral Cost of Profiting from Congo's Suffering.

Introduction. At the 20th Umushyikirano National Dialogue Council in Kigali in February 2026, President Paul Kagame publicly stated that it is acceptable for minerals originating in the Democratic Republic of Congo to pass through Rwanda and be sold internationally. Whilst defending Rwanda's ambitions to become a mineral processing hub, he likened this practice to passengers travelling through Kigali airport en route to other destinations, arguing that whilst wealthy countries benefit most from this trade, Rwanda's participation is normal and justified. However, this framing fundamentally misrepresents a deeply troubling reality: the minerals in question are not legitimately transiting through Rwanda as part of normal trade, but are being extracted under conditions of conflict, violence, and mass suffering imposed by Rwandan-backed forces. The distinction between legitimate cross-border trade and the current situation cannot be overstated. Cross-border commerce between Rwan...

BBC News

Africanews

UNDP - Africa Job Vacancies

How We Made It In Africa – Insight into business in Africa

Migration Policy Institute